Indirect proof 1. (P v F) -> (A v D) 2. A -> (M ^ ~P) 3. D -> (C ^ ~P) / ~P 4. ~~P AIP 5. P 4, DN 6. P v F 5, add. 7. A v D 1,6, MP 8. (M ^ ~P) v (C ^ ~P) 7,2,3, DE (disjunctive elimination) 9. (M v C) ^ ~P 8, distribution 10. ~P ^ (M v C) 9, commutation 11. ~P 10, simp. 12. P^~P 5,11, conj. 13. ~P 4-12 IP Edwin