The answer would be 4! or 24 ways if it didn't matter whether 3 and 4 were side by side or not. From the 4! we must subtract the ways in which they are side by side. There are 2 cases where they can be side by side: Case 1. When the 3 is left of the 4, which means we are arranging these three things: 1, 2, 34 which is 3! or 6 ways. Case 2. When the 4 is left of the 3, which means we are arranging these three things: 1, 2, 43 which is also 3! or 6 ways. So the answer is 4! - 2×3! = 24 - 2×6 = 24 - 12 ways. But, heck, by the time you did all that you could just have listed them all and counted them: 1. 1324 2. 1423 3. 2314 4. 2413 5. 3124 6. 3142 7. 3214 8. 3241 9. 4123 10. 4132 11. 4213 12. 4231 Edwin