SOLUTION: Out of 500 car owners investigated, 400 owned car A and 200 owned car B, 50 owned both A and B. Is this data correct? Explain.

Algebra.Com
Question 940084: Out of 500 car owners investigated, 400 owned car A and 200 owned car B, 50 owned both A and
B. Is this data correct? Explain.

Found 2 solutions by Edwin McCravy, ewatrrr:
Answer by Edwin McCravy(20054)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!

The red circle represents all the car owners that own car A.
The red circle is made up of region w and region x.

The blue circle represents all the car owners that own car B.
The blue circle is made up of region x and region y.

So you see that region x is part of both circle A and B.
Region w is part of circle A but it is NOT part of circle B.
Region y is part of circle B but it is NOT part of circle A.

Therefore 

Region x represents the 50 car owners that own both cars
A and B.  
Region w represents the car owners that own car A but DO NOT
own car B.
Region y represents the car owners that own car B but DO NOT
own car A.
Region z (the area outside the circles but inside the rectangle.

Region z represents the car owners that DO NOT own car A and
also DO NOT own car B.

Therefore we will put the number 50 for region x, since 50 own
both car A and car B.



We are told that 400 owned car A, and the region that contains 50
is part of circle A, so the remaining 400-50=350 that are in circle
A go in region w, so we put 350 in region w: 



We are told that 200 owned car B, and the region that contains 50
is part of circle B, so the remaining 200-50=150 that are in circle
B go in region y, so we put 150 in region y:


 
Now we see that something is wrong, because we were told that
there were only 500 car owners investigated and we already
have 350+50+150 = 550.  So the data we are given is contradictory.

Edwin

Answer by ewatrrr(24785)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
(400-50) + (200-50) + 50 = 550
...
Data correct? No

RELATED QUESTIONS

From a survey of 600 college students, a marketing research company found that 400... (answered by checkley77)
a sample of 80 car owners revealed that 24 owned station wagons and 62 owned cars which... (answered by Theo)
Assist me with this difficult homework problem: 1. A survey of 51 pet owners revealed... (answered by sudhanshu_kmr,josmiceli,richard1234,ewatrrr)
A survey of 51 pet owners revealed that 32 owned dogs, 38 owned cats, and 3 owned neither (answered by edjones)
A survey of 51 pet owners revealed that 32 owned dogs, 38 owned cats, and 3 owned neither (answered by sudhanshu_kmr)
A survey of 53 pet owners revealed that 25 own chickens, 21 owned pigs, 23 owned goats,... (answered by stanbon)
A survey of 51 pet owners revealed that 24 owned dogs, 28 owned cats, 11 owned turtles,... (answered by rfer)
Out of 500 students investigated, 400 studies Hindi, 200 English and 50 both. Is this... (answered by krutarthas)
In a survey of college students, it was found that: 356 owned an iPod 293 owned a... (answered by josmiceli)