Let's divide the 12 up into 3 Ls, 2 R's and 7 E's The 3 L's can only row on the Left. The 2 R's can only row on the Right. The 7 E's can row on Either side. There are 11 cases to consider Case 1. 1R, 7E's Choose the 1R C(2,1) ways Seat the 1R P(4,1) ways Choose and seat the 7E's P(12,7) ways. Total for case 1: C(2,1)P(4,1)P(12,7) = 2×4×P(12,7) = 8P(12,7) Case 2. 2R's, 6E's Choose the 2R's C(2,2)=1 way, Seat the 2R's P(4,2) ways. Choose and seat the 6E's P(12,6) ways. Total for case 2: C(2,2)P(4,2)P(12,6) = 1×12×P(12,6) = 12P(12,6) Case 3. 1L, 7E's Choose the 1L C(3,1) ways, Seat the 1L P(4,1) ways Choose and seat the 7E's P(12,7) ways. Total for case 3: C(3,1)C(4,1)P(12,7) = 3×4×P(12,7) = 12P(12,7) Case 4: 1L, 1R, 6E's Choose the 1L C(3,1) ways, Seat the 1L P(4,1) ways, Choose the 1R C(2,1) ways, Seat the 1R C(4,1) ways, Choose and seat the 6E's P(12,6) ways. Total for case 4: C(3,1)C(4,1)C(2,1)C(4,1)P(12,6)= 3×4×2×4×P(12,6) = 96P(12,6) Case 5: 1L, 2R's, 5E's Choose the 1L C(3,1) ways, Seat the 1L P(4,1) ways, Choose the 2R's C(2,2)=1 way, Seat the 2R's P(4,2) ways, Choose and seat the 5E's P(12,5) ways. Total for case 5: C(3,1)P(4,1)C(2,2)P(4,2)P(12,5) = 3×4×1×12×P(12,5) = 144P(12,5) Case 6: 2L's, 6E's Choose the 2L's C(3,2) ways, Seat the 2L's P(4,2) ways, Choose and seat the 6E's P(12,6) ways. Total for case 6: C(3,2)P(4,2)P(12,6)= 3×12×P(12,6) = 36P(12,6) Case 7: 2L's, 1R, 5E's Choose the 2L's C(3,2) ways, Seat the 2L's P(4,2) ways, Choose the 1R C(2,1) ways, Seat the 1R P(4,1) ways Choose and seat the 5E's P(12,5) ways. Total for case 7: C(3,2)P(4,2)C(2,1)P(4,1)P(12,5) = 3×12×2×4×P(12,5) = 288P(12,5) Case 8: 2L's, 2R's, 4E's Choose the 2L's C(3,2) ways, Seat the 2L's P(4,2) ways, Choose the 2R's C(2,2)=1 way, Seat the 2R's P(4,2) ways Choose and seat the 4E's P(12,4) ways. Total for case 8: C(3,2)P(4,2)C(2,2)P(4,2)P(12,4) 3×12×1×12×P(12,4) = 432P(12,4). Case 9: 3L's, 5E's Choose the 3L's C(3,3)=1 way, Seat the 3L's P(4,3) ways, Choose and seat the 5E's P(12,5) ways. Total for case 6: C(3,3)P(4,3)P(12,5) 1×24×P(12,5) = 24P(12,5) Case 10: 3L's, 1R, 4E's Choose the 3L's C(3,3)=1 way, Seat the 3L's P(4,3) ways, Choose the 1R C(2,1) ways, Seat the 1R P(4,1) ways, Choose and seat the 4E's P(12,4) ways. Total for case 10: C(3,3)P(4,3)C(2,1)P(4,1)P(12,4) 1×24×2×4×P12,4) = 192P(12,4) Case 11: 3L's, 2R's, 3E's Choose the 3L's C(3,3)=1 way, Seat the 3L's P(4,3) ways, Choose the R's C(2,2)=1 way, Seat the 2R's P(4,2) ways, Choose and seat the 3E's P(12,3) ways. Total for case 10: C(3,3)P(4,3)C(2,2)P(4,2)P(12,3) 1×24×1×12×P(12,3) = 288P(12,3) Total = 8P(12,7)+12P(12,6)+12P(12,7)+96P(12,6)+ 144P(12,5)+36P(12,6)+288P(12,5)+432P(12,4)+ 24P(12,5)+192P(12,4)+288P(12,3) = (8+12)P(12,7)+(12+96+36)P(12,6)+ (144+288+24)P(12,5)+(432+192)P(12,4)+ 288P(12,3) = 20P(12,7)+144P(12,6)+456P(12,5)+624P(12,4)+288P(12,3) =Answer = 226765440 Edwin