Divide each member of the set A by 3, using ordinary division, to find the remainder when dividing by 3: 0 = quotient 0/3 3)0 0 0 = remainder 0 = quotient 1/3 3)1 0 1 = remainder 1 = quotient 3/3 3)3 3 0 = remainder 1 = quotient 4/3 3)4 3 1 = remainder 2 = quotient 6/3 3)6 6 0 = remainder 2 = quotient 8/3 3)8 6 2 = remainder D = {(x, y) | x/3 and y/3 have the same remainder} 0/3 has remainder 0 1/3 has remainder 1 3/3 has remainder 0 4/3 has remainder 1 6/3 has remainder 0 8/3 has remainder 2 0/3 and 0/3 have the same remainder 0, so (0,0) is an element of D. 0/3 and 3/3 have the same remainder 0, so (0,3) is an element of D. 0/3 and 6/3 have the same remainder 0, so (0,6) is an element of D. 1/3 and 1/3 have the same remainder 1, so (1,1) is an element of D. 1/3 and 4/3 have the same remainder 1, so (1,4) is an element of D. 3/3 and 0/3 have the same remainder 0, so (3,0) is an element of D. 3/3 and 3/3 have the same remainder 0, so (3,3) is an element of D. 3/3 and 6/3 have the same remainder 0, so (3,6) is an element of D. 4/3 and 1/3 have the same remainder 1, so (4,1) is an element of D. 4/3 and 4/3 have the same remainder 1, so (4,4) is an element of D. 6/3 and 0/3 have the same remainder 0, so (6,0) is an element of D. 6/3 and 3/3 have the same remainder 0, so (6,3) is an element of D. 6/3 and 6/3 have the same remainder 0, so (6,6) is an element of D. 8/3 and 8/3 have the same remainder 2, so (8,8) is an element of D. So D = { (0,0),(0,3),(0,6),(1,1),(1,4),(3,0),(3,3),(3,6),(4,1),(4,4),(6,0),(6,3),(6,6),(8,8) } Edwin