SOLUTION: 4x < 4... I say x=1, my son says it is -1 Who is right?! Thanks

Algebra.Com
Question 552653: 4x < 4... I say x=1, my son says it is -1
Who is right?!
Thanks

Found 2 solutions by AnlytcPhil, Edwin McCravy:
Answer by AnlytcPhil(1807)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
There previously was an error in the solution, which has now been corrected.
You are thinking about equations, not inequalities.  If 4x is less than 4,
which is what 4x < 4 means, then x is less than 1. It cannot be equal to 1.  
In fact x is a variable, and it is not necessarily equal to any one number.
x could be any number less than 1.  It could be , or 0 or 0.7, or -1,
or -46, or -10000000 or -9 or ....  Yes it could be -1, but certainly not
necessarily.

There is no one number that x can only be, because x is a variable, and can
vary its value to any number less than 1.

We make a number line, and shade the part x can be. It cannot be 1,
so we put an open circle there

<==================o------------------
-5 -4 -3 -2 -1  0  1  2  3  4  5

That is the graph of the solution set of the inequality 4x < 4 or x < 1


Edwin

Answer by Edwin McCravy(20063)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
There previously was an error in this solution, which has now been corrected.
You are thinking about equations, not inequalities.  If 4x is less than 4,
which is what 4x < 4 means, then x is less than 1. It cannot be equal to 1.  
In fact x is a variable, and it is not necessarily equal to any one number.
x could be any number less than 1.  It could be , or 0 or 0.7, or -1,
or -46, or -10000000 or -9 or ....  Yes it could be -1, but certainly not
necessarily.

There is no one number that x can only be, because x is a variable, and can
vary its value to any number less than 1.

We make a number line, and shade the part x can be. It cannot be 1,
so we put an open circle there

<==================o------------------
-5 -4 -3 -2 -1  0  1  2  3  4  5

That is the graph of the solution set of the inequality 4x < 4 or x < 1


Edwin

RELATED QUESTIONS

Evaluate |-x-2y| x= -2 y= 3 I say the answer is 4 but my daughter says -4.... (answered by mr.barrett)
(sqrt(x-2)) + 4 - (sqrt(x+2)) + (sqrt(3)) = 6 what is x? some of my friends who... (answered by jsmallt9)
I need help with this equation: 1-2x/3 + x/2 = 1 When I tryed solving this problem I got (answered by blwinbbbles)
1. Factor out the GCF: {{{4x^2+36y^2}}} = is my answer correct cane some one please... (answered by Edwin McCravy)
Says to find the product. (4x-4)(4x+4) I got 16x^2-16 is that right?... (answered by Alan3354)
I am confused on how to simplify this fraction. The text book says the answer is not... (answered by nerdybill)
Hi 3/4 of the boys are equal to 1/3 of the girls. What fraction of the pupils are boys.... (answered by math_tutor2020,greenestamps,MathTherapy,josgarithmetic,ikleyn)
my problem is x^4-16 it says to plug in 1- the square root of 5 in my x spot. I do that... (answered by stanbon)
I hope you can help me.. My daughter is in 4th grade and her homework is "Estimate... (answered by stanbon)