SOLUTION: For 0 < a < b, let h be defined by (1/h) = (1/2)[(1/a) + (1/b)]. Show that a < h < b. The number h is called the harmonic mean of a and b.

Algebra.Com
Question 1207708: For 0 < a < b, let h be defined by (1/h) = (1/2)[(1/a) + (1/b)].
Show that a < h < b. The number h is called the harmonic mean of a and b.

Found 3 solutions by Edwin McCravy, math_tutor2020, mccravyedwin:
Answer by Edwin McCravy(20060)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!

(1)  

Multiply (1) through by a



Multiply (1) through by b





Add ab to all three sides





Divide all three sides by a+b













Edwin

Answer by math_tutor2020(3817)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!

0 < a < b
a < b
1/a > 1/b
1/b < 1/a
1/b < 1/h < 1/a ..... see note below
b > h > a
a < h < b

Note: 1/h is the midpoint of 1/a and 1/b, due to the formula your teacher gave you.
Therefore, 1/h is guaranteed to be between those values.
A way to prove this can be found through this question

Don't forget to flip the inequality signs when applying reciprocals to all sides.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tutor Edwin has a great approach. I'll paraphrase his method slightly.

Let's rewrite the given formula
1/h = (1/2)*(1/a + 1/b)
1/h = (1/2)*(b/(ab) + a/(ab))
1/h = (1/2)*( (a+b)/(ab) )
1/h = (a+b)/(2ab)
h = 2ab/(a+b)
I'll come back to this later.

Then,
a < b turns into a^2 < ab after multiplying both sides by a
a < b turns into ab < b^2 after multiplying both sides by b
Both a and b are positive, so there's no inequality sign flips when multiplication is applied to both sides.
a^2 < ab & ab < b^2 combine to a^2 < ab < b^2

and finally
a^2 < ab < b^2
a^2+ab < ab+ab < b^2+ab ...... adding ab to all sides
a^2+ab < 2ab < b^2+ab
a(a+b) < 2ab < b(a+b)
a < 2ab/(a+b) < b ........... dividing all sides by (a+b)
a < h < b

Since a > 0 and b > 0, we can be certain that a+b > 0 as well of course.
a+b > 0 means dividing both sides by (a+b) will not flip the inequality sign.

Answer by mccravyedwin(408)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
I am tutor Edwin. I have two screen names (Edwin McCravy) and (mccravyedwin)
Here is how I came up with my proof above. 

Here is what I did on scratch paper, not something I would post,
or hand in if I were a student.

I simplified this, getting it down to a "flippable" fraction:







I flipped both sides:



Then (still on scratch paper), I started with the answer (which
is 'illegal', but you can keep your scratch paper a secret.  Your
teacher does not have to see it.  Anyway, I worked backwards from
the answer, even though I had no right to do so. LOL





Then I multiplied through by (a+b), reversed from (b+a)





Then I subtracted ab from all three sides:



Then I noticed I could make two inequalities out of this:

 and 

I divided the first through by a, and the second one through by b,

 and 

They're both the same. And they're something that was given!!! 

Now I must remind you that I had no right to start with the answer
and work backwards.  However, by doing so anyway, I was able to reverse
the process and get a process that I did have a right to do. 

Now if you will compare what I just did with what I did above, you will 
see how I came up with my proof.  That is a method that sometimes helps
you to see how to come up with a proof.  On scratch paper, start with
the answer, work backwards, then see if you can reverse the steps.  Then
toss your scratch paper in the waste basket, and your teacher will never
know. [He/she might suspect though. LOL]

Edwin

RELATED QUESTIONS

For 0 < a < b, let h be defined by 1/h = (1/2)[(1/a) + (1/b)]. Show that a < h < b. (answered by Edwin McCravy,mccravyedwin,ikleyn)
let W be an nx1 matrix such that W^T*W=1.The nxn matrix H=In-2WW^T is called a... (answered by rothauserc)
Let ax^2 + bx + c = 0 be a quadratic equation with no real roots and a,b > 0. Prove that (answered by ikleyn)
Let H = {(1),(13)(24)} in A4 . (a) Show that H is not normal in A4. (b) Show that... (answered by CPhill)
Identify each expression that represents the slope of a tangent to the curve y=1/x+1 at... (answered by ikleyn)
Let h be the function defined by h(x)=x2(2 means squared)-1, where the domain is the set... (answered by nik_consult,PaulAllen65270)
We may define the three means (arithmetic, geometric, and harmonic) of two positive... (answered by amarjeeth123)
If K<1 and h-2k=0 which of the following is true? A)h>0.5 B)h<2 C)h<0.5... (answered by josgarithmetic,ikleyn)
Let f(x)=4x^2+5x+4 and let g(h)= f(1+h)−f(1)/h Determine each of the following:... (answered by MathLover1)