Let the number be x The other tutor's solution is incorrect because he did the no-no of dividing an equation through by the variable x. When you do that you lose a solution. He lost the solution 0. His no-no was as bad if not worse than your misspelling "grateful". J x squared equals x times fourUse the zero factor principle: Setting the first factor equal 0 gives Setting the second factor equal to 0 gives: So the number could be 0 or 4. Edwin