x² + y² + 72 = 12x If it has a graph at all it would be a circle since it has both x² and y² terms with the same coefficient when on the same side of the equation. So we'll try to get it into the form of a circle, which is (x-h)² + (y-k)² = r² x² + y² + 72 = 12x Rearrange by subtracting 12x from both sides, and put the subtacted 12x next to the x² term: x² - 12x + y² + 72 = 0 Subtract 72 from both sides: x² - 12x + y² = -72 Complete the square by takingof -12, the coefficient of x, which gives -6, then square -6 to get +36, and add 36 to both sides: x² - 12x + 36 + y² = -72 + 36 Factor the first three terms, x² - 12x + 36, as (x - 6)(x - 6) which can be written (x - 6)² (x - 6)² + y² = -72 + 36 Write y² as (y - 0)² and combine the terms on the right (x - 6)² + (y - 0)² = -36 oh, oh! There can be no graph because the terms on the left are squares which are both non-negative, making their sum non-negative, yet the term on the right is negative, So this cannot be the equation of any graph. Edwin