SOLUTION: Provide a counter-example to dispute side side angle (ssa) as a sufficient shortcut to determine congruency between triangles.

Algebra.Com
Question 388772: Provide a counter-example to dispute side side angle (ssa) as a sufficient shortcut to determine congruency between triangles.
Answer by Edwin McCravy(20054)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
Provide a counter-example to dispute side side angle (ssa) as a sufficient shortcut to determine congruency between triangles.

Start with an isosceles triangle, say, an equilateral triangle, with all sides
having measure, say, of 10:



Now draw a slanted line from A to D where D is NOT the midpoint
of BC, so that AD has measure, say, 7 and DB has measure 3:




S:   AB and AC have the same measure, 10
S:   The green line AD has the same measure as itself
A:   Angle B and angle C have the same measure of 60°.

However triangles ABD and ACD are NOT congruent.

Comments:

1. You can do this with any isosceles triangle, by drawing a line
   from the vertex of the vertex angle to a point on the base other
   than its midpoint.

2. This version of the SSA theorem can be proved:

SSA Theorem: If two sides and a nonincluded angle of one triangle are
congruent to the corresponding two sides and angle of a second triangle, then
the triangles are either congruent or else the angles opposite the longer
congruent sides are supplementary.  

3.  With regard to 2, we can see in the above case that the two angles 
at D are supplementary.


Edwin

RELATED QUESTIONS

Provide a counter example to dispute SSA as a sufficient shortcut to determine congruency (answered by Edwin McCravy)
provide a counter example to prove that the quotient of two irrational numbers is... (answered by Fombitz)
How would you explain the difference between angle-angle-side, angle-side-angle, and... (answered by addingup,ikleyn)
Pamela says that if the graph of a quadratic function opens upwards, then the related... (answered by josgarithmetic)
a farmer plans to build a triangular fence with side lengths of 500m, 461m, and 408m.... (answered by josgarithmetic)
Determine the solutions to Triangle ABC if: Angle A=100 degrees Side b=6 cm Side... (answered by Alan3354)
Sketch a picture and solve the triangle (find all side lengths and angle measures to... (answered by Edwin McCravy)
Help, help help, these kinds of problems confuse me. A 3judge panel is used to settle a... (answered by stanbon)
is there more than one way to solve inequalities, perhaps a shortcut? can you show me... (answered by MathLover1)