Statement 5 in the response from the other tutor is not valid....
1. BC is congruent to DC indirect proof assumption
2. AB is congruent to AD given
3. AC is congruent to AC
4. Triangles ACB and ACD are congruent SSS
5. Angles BAC and DAC are congruent corresponding parts of congruent triangles
Statement 5 contradicts the given information that angles BAC and DAC are not congruent, so the assumption that BC is congruent to DC is false.
Therefore, BC is not congruent to DC, and the indirect proof is complete.