The other tutor only told you of one case, when the graph extends forever upward above the asymptote y=-3 and also forever below it. This case: (-infinite,-3)U(-3,infinity), but that's not the only possibility. Sometimes the range is just (-infinity,-3) when the graph is all below the asymptote y=-3, and extends forever downward, but no part of the graph is above the asymptote y=-3 Sometimes it's just (-3,infinity), when the graph is all above the asymptote y=-3, and extends forever upward, and no part of the graph is below the asymptote y=-3 And that's not all either: Here's a graph where the range is only (-3,-1):He mentioned the case where the graph crosses the asymptote. In that case the range could be anything and would include -3. So you see there are more possibilities for the range besides just that one. Edwin