For contradiction we assume f(x) is NOT a function. Then there must be two different outputs for the same input, Let a be the input and b and c be the two different outputs, b ≠ c. Then (a,b) and (a,c) are both elements of the relation where b ≠ c. Let y = f(x) =Solve y = for x 6y = x Substitute (a,b) and (a,c) 6b = a, 6c = a then 6b = 6c b = c. That contracts the assumption that b ≠ c Therefore the assumption that f(x) is not a function is false, and therefore f(x) is a function. Edwin