No it does not express the first variable as a function of the second variable {(2, -4)(-2, 0)(2, 2)(-2, 4)(3, -2)(-3, -2)} Note the two blue {(2's are both first coordinates. A function cannot use the same first coordinate twice. Note the two red {(-2's are both first coordinates. A function cannot use the same first coordinate twice. So there are two pairs of ordered pairs that keep this from being a function. Edwin