SOLUTION: The functions f and g are defined as follows: f(x) = sqrt(x+1/x-1) and g(x) = sqrt(x+1)/sqrt(x-1). Explain why functions f and g are not the same function.

Algebra.Com
Question 1164405: The functions f and g are defined as follows:
f(x) = sqrt(x+1/x-1) and g(x) = sqrt(x+1)/sqrt(x-1).
Explain why functions f and g are not the same function.

Found 2 solutions by ikleyn, greenestamps:
Answer by ikleyn(52787)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!
.

These two functions,  f(x)  and  g(x),  have different domain;  

in other words, they are defined in different sets of real numbers.


The domain for function g(x)  is  { x |  x > 1 }.


The domain for function f(x)  is  the set of solutions to THIS inequality

     > 0,   


which is the UNION of two sets

    { x < -1 } U { x > 1 },


where the numerator and denominator BOTH are negative OR BOTH are positive.



See this visual illustration, where I slightly changed function g(x) intently to make the difference visible.


    


    Plot  f(x) =  (red), g(x) =  (green)


    f(x)  has two branches, as you see (two red lines);  

    g(x)  has only one branch (only one green line).


Answered, solved and explained.

Is everything clear to you in my solution ?


`````````````````````````````````

If after reading my post you will have questions,  do not hesitate to post them to me.

If you do,  then please refer to the  ID  number of this problem,  which is  1164405.

The  ID  number is the first number,  which you see in your page in the  UPPER  LEFT  corner.

If you will post to me without referring to this  ID  number,  I will not know to whom to answer.

It is how this forum works.

So,  mentioning this ID is  NECESSARY,  if you want to have two-way communication with me.



Answer by greenestamps(13200)   (Show Source): You can put this solution on YOUR website!


Tutor @ikleyn answered the question you INTENDED to ask; and she answered it well.

On the other hand, answering the question you DID ask is trivial.

The functions



and



are not even remotely similar.

If you are asking a question on a topic like this, you should have enough knowledge of math to know that sometimes parentheses are required to show an expression correctly.


RELATED QUESTIONS

The functions f and g are defined as follows: f(x) = sqrt(x+1/x-1) g(x) =... (answered by ikleyn)
Consider the functions f and g defined by f(x)=sqrt((x+1)/(x-1)) and... (answered by ikleyn)
The functions $f$ and $g$ are defined as follows: \[f(x) =... (answered by ikleyn)
Consider the functions f(x) = sqrt((x+1)/(x-1)) and g(x) = sqrt(x+1)/sqrt(x-1) Explain... (answered by Theo)
Consider the functions \[f(x) =... (answered by MathLover1)
functions f and g are defined as follows: f(x)=x^5 and g(x()= 1/x+1 Evaluate... (answered by Theo)
Consider two functions, f and g, given by: {{{ f(x)= sqrt ( x-1 ) }}} and {{{ g(x)= sqrt... (answered by jim_thompson5910,CharlesG2)
Suppose that the functions F and G are defined for all real numbers as follows.... (answered by josgarithmetic)
Suppose the functions are defined as follows f(x)= {{{ x^2+3 }}} g(x)= {{{ sqrt(x+2) (answered by MathLover1)