No, it's 8.= 8 Multiply both sides by 5 a+b+c+d+e = 40 e = d Substituting a+b+c+d+d = 40 a+b+c+2d = 40 ---------------- = 8 Multiply both sides by 3 a+b+c = 24 Multiply by -1 -a-b-c = -24 Add equals to equals: a+b+c+2d = 40 -a-b-c = -24 --------------- 0+0+0+2d = 16 2d = 16 d = 8 Answer: So the two 8's were removed. There are many. many examples of such sets of 5 numbers but in every case there are 2 8's that are removed. One case is this a=4, b=9, c=11, d=8, e=8 Another case is a=5, b=7, c=12, d=8, e=8 Just make sure that a+b+c = 24 It may be stretching it a bit, but perhaps one case could even be a=8, b=8, c=8, d=8, e=8 because it didn't say more than two couldn't also be equal. But anyway, the answer must be 8. Edwin